THIS SECTION MAY BE COMPLETED BY ANY JURY MEMBER
Comments on rule questions, new interpretations, problems, unpopular Rule 62 (Redress) decisions, summary of the facts, conclusions and decisions of Rule 69 (Allegations of Gross Misconduct) actions, problems with Sailing Instructions or Notice of Race and experience with experimental procedures.
Mostly good weather, and moderate to strong breezes made for a good event for Part 1. Race management focused on target times and performed well with nine courses racing simultaneously. Communication and cooperation between the RC, OA and International Jury was excellent.
Part 2 involved very large Olympic classes, the Laser Radial Men’s World Championships, the EUROSAF Para Sailing European Championships, nine courses racing and volatile weather. As storm cells moved through, the RC worked diligently to run races between fronts. This made for excellent racing for competitors, but long days on the water for the RC, and late nights for the PC ashore. On two days the RC ran three races for one fleet in the early afternoon followed by three races for another fleet in the evening, ending between 2100 and 2200. Medal Racing on the last day of Part 2 involved two medal courses with three umpire boats on each course. The remaining six jury boats were assigned to fleets not conducting medal races.
This large international jury of 26 (18 IJ’s and 8 NJ’s) met each morning for a 45 minute NJ training session, followed by a 45 minute whole jury meeting. The jury meeting consisted of plans for the day, review of significant cases from the previous day’s hearings, and expert presentations from some of the IJ’s on significant topics. The goals were to improve consistency of decisions, increase efficiency, and share “best practices”. 12 jury boats were on-the-water daily enforcing RRS 42. Post-racing the jury divided up into 4 properly constituted panels (5 judges each) and 2 arbitrators. Cases not settled or inappropriate for arbitration were sent to jury panels. This jury worked very hard. Long days and late evenings. Many nights the jury had dinner together which led to greater cohesion and lively rules discussions.
The International Jury held several hearings where support persons had broken rules. Those hearings resulted in the support persons being excluded from going on the water for one day.
Between Kieler Woche Part 1, and Part 2, the event generated one 69 report to the International Jury. This report was regarding a competitor, not racing, who was interfering with the start of a fleet racing. The panel decided the competitor had committed an act of misconduct, and proceeded to penalize the competitor with a DSQ for his next race.
- USADS153
Ner of classes: 13
Entries: 709
Ner of Countries represented: 31
Ner of Races sailed: 184
Ner of requests for redress: 7
Ner of requests for redress for OCS: 0
Ner of requests for OCS granted: 0
Total number of hearings: 21
Total number of arbitrations: 5
Number of % penalties: 30
To be completed only if Appendix P was applied.
Number of First Penalties (Appendix P2.1): 97
Number of Second Penalties (Appendix P2.2): 20
Number of Third Penalties (Appendix P2.3): 2
P2.3 Subsequent Penalties: 0
Event:
Kieler Woche 2018 Part 1
Date Event Started
16 June 2018
Event Location:
Kiel Yacht Club, GER
Group Event belongs:
B - Central Europe
Jury Chairman's name:
L. Douglas Sloan
Jury chairman's email:
d.sloan@puretecbio.com
Judge submitting report:
L. Douglas Sloan
Email of judge submitting report:
d.sloan@puretecbio.com
PRO at event :
Nino Shmueli
PRO sailorID and status:
( IRO )
Email of PRO:
nino.shmueli@gmail.com
Was this an International Jury Panel ?
Yes
Please name each judge (including the chairman) and their country and IJ or NJ certification. one per line
Yuval Zur ISRYZ1 / NJ
Paul Zupan USAPZ9 / IJ
Barbara Stodal GERBS25 / NJ
L. Douglas Sloan USADS153 / IJ
johan sjostrand SWE Snn16 / NJ
Mathias Rebholz GERMR11 / IJ
Enrico Pilla ITAEP45 / NJ
Paul Pascoe AUSPP3 / IJ
Christina Ortendahl SWECO2 / IJ
Johannes Liebig GERJL19 / NJ
Anastazja Lewandowska POLAL01 / IJ
Michal Jodlowski POLMJ1 / IJ
Francisco SG Jauregui MEXFJ1 / IJ
Hermann Herburger GERHH30 / NJ
Laura Hatje GERLH15 / NJ
Timo Haß GERTH8 / IJ
Manuel Gamito PORMG5 / IJ
Bojan Gale SLOBG1 / IJ
Thorsten Doebbeler GERTD7 / IJ
Johannes Diefenbach GERJD12 / IJ
Lance Burger RSALB1 / IJ
Adrian Bauder SUIAB6 / IJ
Ron Barak ISRRB5 / IJ
Jacob Mossin Andersen DENJA8 / IJ
Michael Alison NZLMA3 / IJ
Yuval Zur ISRYZ1 / NJ
Paul Zupan USAPZ9 / IJ
Barbara Stodal GERBS25 / NJ
L. Douglas Sloan USADS153 / IJ
johan sjostrand SWE Snn16 / NJ
Mathias Rebholz GERMR11 / IJ
Enrico Pilla ITAEP45 / NJ
Paul Pascoe AUSPP3 / IJ
Christina Ortendahl SWECO2 / IJ
Johannes Liebig GERJL19 / NJ
Anastazja Lewandowska POLAL01 / IJ
Michal Jodlowski POLMJ1 / IJ
Francisco SG Jauregui MEXFJ1 / IJ
Hermann Herburger GERHH30 / NJ
Laura Hatje GERLH15 / NJ
Timo Haß GERTH8 / IJ
Manuel Gamito PORMG5 / IJ
Bojan Gale SLOBG1 / IJ
Thorsten Doebbeler GERTD7 / IJ
Johannes Diefenbach GERJD12 / IJ
Lance Burger RSALB1 / IJ
Adrian Bauder SUIAB6 / IJ
Ron Barak ISRRB5 / IJ
Jacob Mossin Andersen DENJA8 / IJ
Michael Alison NZLMA3 / IJ
The information contained within this report may be shared with any appropriate member of World Sailing committees or staff for the purpose of evaluating your report.